top of page

What Happened to Net Neutrality?

8 hours ago
3 min read

For anyone who spent much time online in 2017, net neutrality was nearly impossible to avoid. Reddit communities urged users to contact Congress, websites staged online protests, and Federal Communications Commission Chairman Ajit Pai became one of the internet’s most criticized federal regulators.


Some warnings were dramatic. Critics envisioned internet providers eventually selling access to websites in packages similar to cable television, charging customers more for social media, streaming or gaming. Others warned that providers could slow websites or favor companies willing to pay for better access.


Nearly nine years later, those predictions largely did not materialize.


Americans still generally pay an internet provider for a connection and then use that connection to access Netflix, YouTube, Google, social media and other websites without purchasing separate packages. But the debate behind those warnings involved a real question: How much control should internet providers have over the traffic traveling through their networks?


Net neutrality is the principle that internet service providers should generally treat internet traffic equally rather than favoring or disadvantaging particular websites or services.

Under President Barack Obama, the FCC adopted its 2015 Open Internet Order, which prohibited broadband providers from blocking lawful websites, intentionally slowing certain traffic or accepting payment to give some services preferential treatment. The FCC also classified broadband under Title II of the Communications Act, giving the agency broader regulatory authority.


Supporters argued the rules were needed because internet providers could have financial incentives to favor their own services or large companies capable of paying for faster delivery. Without restrictions, they argued, smaller competitors could eventually be placed at a disadvantage.


Pai and other opponents argued the rules imposed unnecessary government regulation on an internet that had developed successfully under a lighter regulatory system. They also warned Title II regulation could discourage investment in broadband networks.


The disagreement was not necessarily over whether consumers should have access to an open internet. Both sides generally supported that principle. The fight was over whether federal regulation was necessary to guarantee it.


On Dec. 14, 2017, the FCC voted 3-2 to repeal the Obama-era framework. The changes took effect in June 2018.


The immediate aftermath was far less dramatic than many online predictions. Internet providers did not begin widely dividing websites into paid packages, major services did not suddenly become inaccessible, and the basic way Americans used the internet remained largely unchanged.


That gave opponents of the rules evidence for their argument that the warnings had been exaggerated.


But it did not entirely settle the debate. The original regulations were intended to prevent blocking, throttling and paid prioritization before those practices became widespread. Several states also adopted their own protections, while providers remained subject to other consumer protection and competition laws.


The federal government reversed course again under President Joe Biden. In 2024, the FCC voted to restore net neutrality regulations and again classify broadband under Title II.

That effort was struck down by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit in January 2025. The court ruled that broadband is an information service under federal law and that the FCC did not have authority to impose the Title II framework.


The decision left the United States without nationwide federal net neutrality rules similar to those adopted in 2015 and made congressional action the clearest path toward permanent national requirements.


Nearly a decade after the internet erupted over net neutrality, the worst predictions did not come true. Consumers are not generally paying their internet providers for separate Netflix, social media or gaming packages, and widespread blocking of popular websites did not follow the repeal.


But the underlying question never disappeared: Should internet providers simply choose not to favor or restrict certain internet traffic, or should federal law prohibit them from doing so?

The online panic of 2017 may have overstated what was about to happen. The policy debate behind it was considerably more complicated — and it remains unresolved.

 
 

Subscribe Form

Sign up to receive text updates. By participating, you agree to the terms and privacy policy for recurring messages from Sangamon Reporter to the phone number you provide. No consent required to buy. Msg and data rates may apply.

  • facebook
  • generic-social-link

The Sangamon Reporter LLC

P.O. Box 13441.Springfield, IL 62791

Publisher: Karen Hasara

Email

bottom of page